Should fans give Marvel another shot?
For a while, the answer was a clear: Nope!
Since Avengers: Endgame, Marvel has released 14 films. Two were great: Black Widow and Spider-Man: No Way Home. The rest? Inadequate. Unworthy of our time.
Marvel’s Strongest Effort Since No Way Home
Thunderbolts* is different. If you’ve been waiting for a reason to re-engage, this is it. Just… don’t start here. Most of these characters originate elsewhere. This is a reengagement, not an introduction. Much of the good is nostalgia-driven.
The marketing is clever. One piece of trailer footage—featuring a character who dies before the scene actually occurs—is a fake-out. Three days after release, the theatrical poster transforms and the film is seemingly retitled!
The altered IMAX countdown featured Fantastic Four iconography. Subtle hype, expertly placed. I didn’t watch the trailer, but still felt the spark: Perhaps things won’t be so bad after all…
e-Ticketing for the Economist
Don’t use Fandango.
AMC or Regal apps are cleaner. Fewer traps.
Fandango auto-checks charity boxes and charges more. Their schedule UI is solid, but they leave out key cinemas like Nashville’s Belcourt.
IMAX only ran briefly – but if it returns, use it.
Still worth seeing in Standard.
A Thunderbolts critique
The lore’s interwoven deep. Captain America: Brave New World plays heavily into the backstory. Falcon and the Winter Soldier threads are present too. We even hear dialogues justify the permanence of The Avenger’s end.
If you know the three Russians by heart, you’re in too deep. I need the refresher:
- Alexei Shostakov (Red Guardian, played by David Harbour)
- His daughters:
- Natasha Romanoff (aka Black Widow, Scarlett Johansson)
- Yelena Belova (aka Black Widow, Florence Pugh)
Same dad, same mom. Both unmarried. Three different, Russian last names.
Natasha Romanoff
I’m not a fan of resurrecting dead characters. Comics do it all the time, and it cheapens everything. This Thunderbolts* confirms: Black Widow is gone. Scarlett Johansson’s arc is over. Permanently.
It’s the right call. But a hard one.
Yelena Belova
This film is Florence Pugh’s now. And smartly so.
Her character’s flaw – talking over people, ignoring advice – is somehow both endearing and infuriating. It creates tension. Her performance may not be flawless, but she wrangles some clunky jokes. Flo carries the weight of imperfect writing.
Nobody replaces Scarlett. But Florence carves her own space – darker, snarkier, less serious, still compelling. The camera loves her differently, but just as hungrily.
Yelena even ventures into a metaphysical realm – something Marvel’s ham-fisted in recent years (Quantum Realm, Multiverse of Madness, Deadpool & Wolverine). But this one’s clean. The fantasy space feels tactile, well-measured and narratively necessary. Not just a visual stunt.
Alexei Shostakov
David Harbour gives everything. Every scene. He’s fully in character – vulnerable, absurd, inspired. He believes in heroism. You can feel it radiating off him.
At times, his performance transcends genre. It becomes a metaphor – for genuine acting, for inspired filmmaking, for the potential of comic cinema. He argues for the value of art, and he does it while dressed like a Russian super soldier.
That’s something.
Can you please just review Thunderbolts?
Florence and Harbour together? They’re acting on a different tier than most of their co-stars.
No disrespect to Sebastian Stan or Wyatt Russell. Who are both excellent here. Their performances tend toward mechanical on occasion.
Russell’s dialogue is bloated. The action demands are heavy. But he pulls it off.
Falcon headlines a film. Bucky and Walker show up here. But Agent 13? Missing!
Moving along with the Thunderbolts review…
Not Another Suicide Squad
The comparisons are inevitable – but inaccurate. SS assembles unknown villains and forces them into death missions. T-bolts brings together known antiheroes, each with deeper roots in the MCU.
Ayer’s Squad introduced Harley Quinn. This one reintroduces Florence Pugh and David Harbour at full strength. And unlike Suicide Squad, the government antagonist (Julia Louis-Dreyfus as Valentina Allegra de Fontaine) isn’t just a puppetmaster – she’s commonly regarded as a crooked politician. She’s being investigated, and much of the film’s narrative tension centers around exposing her.
Her survival instincts border on Lex Luthor levels of absurdity. She’s pure evil. Not in a cartoonish way – just in the bureaucratic, untouchable way that makes your skin crawl.
To Valentina, people are tools – discardable, replaceable and always beneath her.
Bankrobber Garb
Marvel’s still stuffing background extras into black ski masks. This time, they’re generic military goons. Covering their faces doesn’t make them less human – or their deaths less visible. It’s lazy. And distracting.
After all, Marvel’s got four films on the horizon.
Those two Avengers films have Anthony and Joe Russo listed as the directors.
See? Hope.
This writer will dare to dream. For now, Thunderbolts* earns Marvel one more shot.
★★★★ ★★★★
TLDR? Read my briefer analysis on IMDb or, for max brevity, Letterboxd.
For more Marvel read The Fantastic Four: First Steps. Check out Iron Man 3!









