A friend’s drunken gesticulation spills wine onto your lap. The appetizers drown beneath the tide from the upturned water pitcher. You wipe yourself off. Try to salvage what’s left.
That’s Captain America 4 – better than most of Marvel’s post-Endgame output, yet still inadequate.
Much holds attention – until it doesn’t. Some things we can set aside:
A) The shadow of Endgame. A title so bad it borders on evil. Suspension of disbelief never recovered, and that condition remains incurable.
B) Marvel’s “More = Better” philosophy. Introducing a new Falcon feels rushed. Forced upon the audience before Sam Wilson’s Captain America can find his footing. Danny Ramirez’s performance struggles under Anthony Mackie’s shadow, often feeling artificial. Meanwhile, the film stacks its supporting cast with characters that feel more like a demographic checklist than an organic ensemble. The one thing Neo-Falcon can’t be is Hispanic, right? That would be too obvious. Good stories don’t aim for the bullseye; they earn their way there.
C) Leila Taylor’s presence. She feels like an obligatory inclusion rather than a necessary part of the story. Leila is played by Xosha Roquemore. Her name alone seems selected for “diverse casting” appeal. Leila never justifies her role. If the President’s head of security is female it makes sense she’s trained by the Black Widow program. But that position already belongs to Ruth Bat-Seraph. So what purpose does Leila serve? She adds nothing to the plot, yet still lingers in the frame, another checkmark in the studio’s balancing act.
D) The de-elevation of hand-to-hand combat. The Captain America films were once defined by their fight choreography – grounded, inventive, and precise. Every blow in Captain America: The Winter Soldier feels deliberate. Not here. The fights are sloppier, less tactile and increasingly reliant on CGI bandaids.
E) The imaginary earpieces. Half the crew on set wears a surveillance headset, yet heroes send transmissions telepathically.
A devoted fan forgives these flaws, but there’s a breaking point. It arrives with the scene – the one reeking of cheap reshoots.
Cap and his new Falcon brawl with lazily costumed thugs, their masks concealing their identity as recycled stuntmen. (Deadpool 3 suffers the same issue – this needs to stop.)

The choreography is amateurish. The thugs wield tasers instead of guns. Filmmakers hastily tie up any loose ends with CGI trickery. Cap’s shield ricochets in whatever direction they need it to.
The scene is so obviously shot on a soundstage. So inessential. So painful.
Please stop titling films after novels when the texts don’t relate (looking at you Wonder Woman 1984!)
Is it even worth trying one soaked croquette?
★ ★ ★ ★
Fractions of this review available at IMDb and Letterboxd.









